Hard Clash, Soft Clash And Workflow Clash.
BIM coordination talks about three kinds of clash. They look alike on a list, but they are found differently and fixed by different people.
Two Solid Things In The Same Place.
A hard clash is a geometric collision: two elements occupy the same space. A duct passing through a structural beam is the standard example, and so is a pipe through a column or a wall built through a staircase.
Hard clashes are the ones that cannot be built as drawn. They are found by testing the shapes of the elements against each other, which is what clash detection software does first.
Too Close, Even Though Nothing Touches.
A soft clash, also called a clearance clash, is a breach of the space an element needs around it. A valve needs room to be reached, a switchboard needs clear floor in front of it, and insulated pipework needs room for its insulation and for maintenance.
Nothing collides, yet the design cannot be built or run properly. Soft clashes are found by giving the element a larger invisible zone and testing that zone instead of the element itself.
A Conflict In Time, Not In Space.
A workflow clash, also called a 4D clash, is a conflict in the construction schedule or sequence. Two crews need the same area at the same time, or a wall is scheduled to close before the pipes inside it are installed.
Workflow clashes are found by linking the model to the programme, and they are solved by planners as much as by designers.
Not Every Hard Clash Is A Problem.
A pipe through a sleeve made for it is a hard clash by geometry and no problem by design. A socket in its own wall is the same. Good coordination separates these intended overlaps from the ones that need action, and that is where most of the time goes on a large model.
The Three Types Compared.
Where Clashes Usually Appear.
- Structure and mechanical: ducts through beams and slabs that have no opening for them
- Structure and plumbing: drainage pipes that must fall at a set gradient running into beams
- Electrical and mechanical: cable trays crossing ducts in the same ceiling void
- Fire protection and everything else: sprinkler mains and heads under ducts and lights
- Architecture and services: a ceiling height that leaves too little room for the deepest duct
- Within one discipline: duplicate elements copied twice, or two pipes of one system crossing
Choosing What To Fix First.
Not all clashes are equal. A duct through a load-bearing beam needs the structural engineer and may change the structure; a cable tray touching a ceiling tile needs a small move. Coordinators usually rank clashes by what is involved (structure, fire-rated walls, large plant), by how deep the overlap is, and by how many other clashes share the same cause.
Common routing practice also decides who moves. Gravity drainage has to keep its fall, so other services usually move around it. Large ducts are hard to reroute, so smaller pipes and trays usually move first. Writing these priorities down saves the same debate in every meeting.
What The Platform Checks.
SpaceDesignX checks hard clashes, within each file and between disciplines, and grades each one: Major when a person must act, Minor for zero clearance or an overlap within drawing tolerance, and Expected when the overlap is by design, such as a pipe through its own sleeve. Each gets a severity from 0 to 100 with its reason. Clearance zones and construction sequence are outside the clash check.
Common Questions.
What Are Hard Clashes, Soft Clashes And Workflow Clashes?
A hard clash is two solid elements in the same space, a soft clash breaches a required clearance, and a workflow clash is a conflict in schedule or sequence. SpaceDesignX checks hard clashes, within each file and between disciplines, and grades each as Major, Minor or Expected. Clearances are measured too, against distances your team sets per pair of disciplines; construction sequence is outside the clash check.
What Do Major, Minor And Expected Mean?
Major clashes need a person: a duct through a load-bearing wall with no opening, for example. Minor clashes are zero clearance or an overlap within drawing tolerance. Expected clashes are by design, such as a pipe through its own sleeve. Each gets a severity from 0 to 100 and a plain reason, and Expected ones stay out of the problem counts.
How Does SpaceDesignX Avoid False Positives?
By recognising what is intended. Planned openings, sleeves, a socket in its own wall and two parts of one pipe system meeting at a joint are classed Expected, with the reason, and are left out of the problem counts. The thresholds behind each verdict are settings that your own experts can change.
What Is A Clash Group?
A Clash Group is a set of clash pairs that share one cause, such as ductwork passing through one slab. Deciding once for the group settles all of its pairs, which turns hundreds of rows into a short list of decisions.
See Your Own Model In SpaceDesignX.
Send us a model you know well. We will walk you through it live in the products that fit your work: approvals, clash detection, defects and handover, or carbon.