Guide

What Is Clash Detection In BIM?

Clash detection finds the places where parts of a building design occupy the same space. This guide explains what it checks, how it works, and how teams turn the result into fixes.

The Short Answer

Finding Conflicts Before They Reach Site.

A building is designed by several teams: architects, structural engineers, and the services engineers for mechanical, electrical, plumbing and fire protection. Each team builds its own digital model. Clash detection combines those models and tests whether any element of one passes through, or sits too close to, an element of another.

A duct that cuts through a beam is a clash. So is a pipe that runs through a column, or a cable tray that crosses a sprinkler main in the same spot. Found on screen, each one is a change to a drawing. Found on site, each one is a rework order, a delay and an argument about who pays.

How It Works

Combine, Test, Review, Fix, Repeat.

  • The discipline models are combined into one federated model, usually from IFC files that every authoring tool can export
  • Software compares the shape of every element with its neighbours and lists the pairs that collide
  • A coordinator reviews the list, decides which clashes are real, and assigns them to the team that should change its design
  • The designers change their models and issue a new version
  • The check runs again on the new version, and the list is compared with the last one to see what was resolved
The Hard Part

A Long List Is Not The Same As A Decision.

On a large project the first check can return thousands of clashes. Many are intended, such as a pipe passing through a sleeve made for it, and many repeat a single cause, such as one duct run crossing one slab in forty places. Most of the coordination work goes into sorting that list.

Tools therefore differ less in whether they find clashes than in how they help with the sorting: grouping clashes by cause, recognising the intended ones, ranking the rest, and checking that a proposed move does not simply create new clashes elsewhere. SpaceDesignX does this as AI Clash Detection.

Who Is Involved

The People Behind A Clash Check.

BIM Coordinator

Combines the models, runs the check, sorts the results and chairs the coordination meeting.

Discipline Designers

Change their own models: the mechanical engineer reroutes the duct, the architect moves the wall.

Structural Engineer

Decides whether a beam or slab may take a new opening, and where. Nobody else should.

Contractor

Checks that the coordinated design can be built in a sensible order, with room to install and maintain it.

When To Run It

Run It On Every New Model Version.

Early in design, models are coarse: a duct may be a single line and a beam a rough box. Clash checks at this stage find big conflicts, such as a plant room that does not fit, but report little detail.

The most useful period is detailed design, when services are routed through ceiling voids and risers. Here a weekly check on each new model version catches problems while each one is a small redesign. A full check before the drawings are issued for tender or construction gives the team a clean starting point on site.

Running the check only at milestones lets problems pile up. A list of three thousand clashes from three months of work is much harder to resolve than three hundred from one week.

Tolerances And Rules

Deciding What Counts As A Clash.

Two settings shape every clash result. The first is the tolerance: overlaps smaller than a few millimetres are usually ignored, because they come from rounding in the authoring tools, not from a real conflict. Set it too strict and the list fills with noise; set it too loose and real problems slip through.

The second is which pairs to test. Most teams test each discipline against the others, then each discipline against itself for duplicates and crossing pipes. Some pairs are tested with a clearance, such as a pipe needing insulation space or a switchboard needing room in front of it. Writing these choices down as rules makes the results repeatable from one version to the next.

Common Mistakes

Why Clash Checks Disappoint.

  • Models are not in shared coordinates, so the whole building appears to clash with itself
  • One discipline sends an old version, and the meeting discusses problems that were already fixed
  • Everything is tested against everything with no rules, and nobody reads past the first page
  • Clashes have no owner and no due date, so they are discussed every week and fixed by nobody
  • A fix for one clash creates two new ones elsewhere, found only at the next check
  • Issues are tracked in a spreadsheet, separate from the model, and drift out of date
Next

Where To Go From Here.

The next guide explains the main types of clash: hard, soft and workflow. To see the sorting done on a real model, request a demo and send an IFC set you know well.

Questions

Common Questions.

What Is Clash Detection In BIM?

Clash detection finds the places where elements of a building model occupy the same space, such as a duct passing through a beam. It runs on the combined model of every discipline, so the problem is found on screen during design instead of on site, where fixing it costs far more.

What Is AI Clash Detection, And How Is It Different From Traditional Clash Detection?

AI clash detection goes beyond listing overlaps. Traditional tools report every geometric overlap and leave the sorting to people. SpaceDesignX classes each clash as Major, Minor or Expected with a 0 to 100 severity and its reason, collects related clashes into Clash Groups, and proposes a fix that is checked against the whole building.

What Do Major, Minor And Expected Mean?

Major clashes need a person: a duct through a load-bearing wall with no opening, for example. Minor clashes are zero clearance or an overlap within drawing tolerance. Expected clashes are by design, such as a pipe through its own sleeve. Each gets a severity from 0 to 100 and a plain reason, and Expected ones stay out of the problem counts.

What Is A Clash Group?

A Clash Group is a set of clash pairs that share one cause, such as ductwork passing through one slab. Deciding once for the group settles all of its pairs, which turns hundreds of rows into a short list of decisions.

All Questions

See Your Own Model In SpaceDesignX.

Send us a model you know well. We will walk you through it live in the products that fit your work: approvals, clash detection, defects and handover, or carbon.